THE BAKING NOTEBOOK / BAKE WITH DISCARD
Sourdough Discard Substitution Chart
Discard is not a free extra ingredient in a recipe: it already contains flour and water. Use this chart to subtract those amounts from a compatible recipe before mixing, while remembering that discard acidity and leavening strength can still affect the result.
How much flour and water does discard replace?
At 100% hydration, 100 g discard contains about 50 g flour and 50 g water. Subtract those amounts from the original recipe to preserve its flour-and-water totals.
01 / A KITCHEN REFERENCE
Look up your discard substitution
Replace the flour and water already inside your discard.
| Discard | Flour replaced | Water replaced |
|---|---|---|
| 50 g | 25 g | 25 g |
| 100 g | 50 g | 50 g |
| 150 g | 75 g | 75 g |
| 200 g | 100 g | 100 g |
The table uses 100%-hydration discard. Other ingredients and leavening remain recipe-specific.
A LITTLE CONTEXT GOES A LONG WAY
How to use this guide
Choose a discard weight
Use the 50–200 g lookup for 100%-hydration discard. For a different hydration, switch to the main Discard Calculator.
Subtract from a compatible recipe
Only substitute as much flour and water as the original recipe can spare; never produce a negative ingredient amount.
When substitution changes the result
Acidity, milk, eggs and leavening behavior are not made equivalent simply by matching flour and water grams.
CHECK THE NUMBERS
A worked example
400g flour + 300g water original recipe; replace with 100g 100% discard → add 350g fresh flour + 250g fresh water.
Flour from discard = discard mass ÷ (1 + hydration ÷ 100). Water from discard = discard mass − flour from discard. Subtract those contributions from the original recipe.
THE QUESTIONS BAKERS ASK
A few things
you might be wondering.
Clear answers for this part of your bake.
01How much flour is in 100 g sourdough discard?+
At 100% hydration, 100 g discard contains 50 g flour and 50 g water. To preserve a recipe’s totals, remove those amounts from the fresh ingredients. Discard at another hydration has a different split.
02Can I add discard without subtracting ingredients?+
Adding discard on top of a recipe changes its flour and water totals, hydration and possibly texture. This chart instead helps preserve those totals by showing what to subtract. It does not guarantee the same acidity or leavening.
03Can discard replace active starter in bread?+
Discard may be less active than freshly fed starter, so an equal weight is not a reliable replacement for active starter. Flour-and-water substitution and leavening are separate questions. Follow a tested recipe’s instructions for yeast or other leavening.
04Does the chart work for stiff discard?+
Yes. The default is 100% hydration, but you can enter the actual hydration to update the chart. Stiff discard contains more flour and less water per gram. Use the Discard Calculator for a detailed recipe adjustment.
05What if the original recipe has too little water?+
If the discard provides more water than the recipe allows, do not show a negative amount; choose less discard or a different recipe. Milk, eggs and butter contain solids or fat as well as water. A simple water subtraction does not preserve their role in the recipe.